Low-Carbon Tech, an Infant Industry in Need of Protection

How to react to global warming? How do wean ourselves off that harmful oil – and still prosper?

I maintained that we’d better be safe with Sinn‘s fears of a Green Paradox than sorry without him, notwithstanding the uncertainties of his argument.

Economist Hans-Werner Sinn is no easy read for a green German: he pretty much pulls german and European green policy into pieces. Much of his critique is plausible, if unsettling: without international cooperation, much of our unilateral efforts may be in vain.

But there’s one thing where I wholeheartedly disagree with Sinn: low-carbon technology, for the time being, does indeed require subsidies.

Renewables / via Flickr, originally uploaded by Chad Johnson

Renewables / via Flickr, originally uploaded by Chad Johnson

Yes, it may be hard for states to pick winners, but low-carbon technology still needs infant industry incubation, if it is to sustain us in the near future.

Continue reading

Uncertainty and Responsibility in Climate Change: A Case for Alarmism and New Risk Management

english

I was recently tasked to prepare a presentation on the political economy questions of climate change: How expensive is saving the climate? And who should shoulder the costs?

As I prepared the presentation for Dr. Mildner’s “States & Markets” seminar, it occurred to me that to answer these questions, we first have to understand the risks and uncertainties of climate change. The real questions, I thought were then different ones:

  • How do we manage risk, and respond to uncertainty?
  • How do we treat extreme low probability and high consequence events?
  • How do we respond to asymmetric risks?

The more I learned about current risk modeling of the climatic and economic impacts of global warming, the more worried I became. I realized, that climate change (as, incidentally, lessons learned from the financial crisis), requires us to rethink how we manage systemic, interdependent, asymmetric and extreme risks as well as uncertainty.

“Act Now!”

(Friends of the Earth InternationalThe Big Ask)

I agree, we need to act now, and we need to ask strongly.

Yes, this video simplifies. Yes, it dramatizes. And Yes, it scares us.

And it should. For when everything is at stake, alarmism is not irrational, it becomes a moral imperative and different risk management is necessary.
Continue reading