In AfPak, Iraq and elsewhere: If you break it, you buy it

Since the two GBU-38 500lb bombs struck the fuel tankers in Kunduz province, Afghanistan and engulfed by-standing civilians in a giant fireball on September 4, 2009, what have we really learned?

I fear that amid all the self-righteous blameshifting and  frantic second-guessing of the attack, which was launched from an American fighter jet, but ordered by the German Oberst Klein, we haven’t learned nearly enough.

We haven’t learned nearly enough about this mayhem of a failed state and the chaos that even the well-intentioned regime changes or peacemaking bring.

We haven’t learned nearly enough about the nightmares, that result all too often, when the high and mighty West comes to the rescue.

Tank Graffiti, via Flickr, originally uploaded by Luodanli

Tank Graffiti, via Flickr, originally uploaded by Luodanli

ISAF, MNF-I Go Home? – not so fast.

This isn’t a simple question of surging or withdrawing: from this nightmare, there is no waking up.

We need to learn a lesson, of what happens when we disrupt and exploit divided, traditional societies, equip them with technology and weaponry far outmatching their level of development. From this responsibility, there is no escaping.

It’s a simple lesson, we all accept before entering a store: if you break it, you buy it.

Continue reading

Failure in Iraq: It’s Hobbes First, Then Jefferson/Madison

On May 1st, 2003 when then President George W. Bush, declared the end of major combat operations and the mission Iraqi Freedom to be “accomplished” aboard the USS Abraham Lincoln aircraft carrier, much of the failure and dying in Iraq still lay ahead.

Mission Accomplished Banner on USS Abraham Lincoln

Mission Accomplished Banner on the USS Abraham Lincoln

The invasion, starting on March 19, 2003, had been a remarkable military success, on schedule and with comparatively few casualties (139 US troops and approximately 7,500 civilians before May 1, 2003 according to CNN and Iraq Body Count estimates, respectively).

In the insurgency that followed (and has recently slightly abated), more than 4,000 US troops and 60,000 Iraqi civilians were killed (ibid.). To this date, seven years after “major hostilities” ended, the country is still plagued by sectarian violence and crime, marred by economic hardship and destruction and paralyzed by deeply divided politics and dysfunctional government. The vision and partial casus belli of the “Coalition of the Willing”, to turn Iraq into a role model liberal democracy for the Middle East, has not materialized. Instead, the suffering and dying continues.

What happened?

Continue reading

BRIMUN 2007: mission accomplished?

english

North Atlantic Council, Bremen International Model United Nations 2007. Bremen State Parliament, Spring 2007.

North Atlantic Council, Bremen International Model United Nations 2007. Bremen State Parliament, Spring 2007.

Today was the last day of Bremen International Model United Nations (BRIMUN) conference, a simulation of international affairs for students, hosted by Jacobs’ own Model United Nations society. I had the pleasure to chair the North Atlantic Council, together with my colleague and friend Matthias. After five days of intense debating, international diplomacy, military confrontations and resolution drafting, the conference has today culminated in its closing ceremony, held in Bremen’s state parliament, the Bremische Bürgerschaft.

Matthias and me much enjoyed working with the 12 dedicated, competent and, well, probably most pacifistic delegates that a military alliance has ever seen. 

Continue reading

BRIMUN 2007 is coming, topics finalized

english

Secretary General of BRIMUN 2005, Gero Elerd. BRIMUN 2005 / Campus Jacobs University Bremen, Spring 2005.

Secretary General of BRIMUN 2005, Gero Elerd. BRIMUN 2005 / Campus Jacobs University Bremen, Spring 2005.

After participating in 2005 as a Security Council delegate and chairing in 2006, I am looking forward to BRIMUN’s 2007 session, during which I will chair the North Atlantic Council together with my colleague Matthias Bröcheler.

We have today finalized the list of topics that “our” committee will debate and have detailed out or ideas about the crises simulations during the conference. We are hoping for fruitful discussions, a challenging geo-political crisis and, of course, a thrilling social program (a.k.a. parties).

The North Atlantic Council is the main political decision making body of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO). More information on the topics and the committee can be found at www.brimun.org.

Bremen International Model United Nations (BRIMUN) is a United Nations simulation, hosted annually by the Model United Nations Society of International University Bremen.

Please find attached the complete study guide for the North Atlantic Council, written by me and my colleague Matthias Bröcheler.